In a mixer jar / blender add 1 onion , garlic , ginger and blend to a smooth paste.
Heat 2 tablespoon of oil / ghee in a pan , add cumin seeds , bay leaf , cloves , cinnamon sticks , cardamom and red chilly . Saute till fragrant.
Add onion paste and saute till raw smell of onion and garlic goes off.
Now add in red chilli powder , turmeric powder and coriander powder,hing , mix well everything.
Keep the flame on low heat , beat curds well and add into to the above onion and spice mixture.
Mix well everything on cook on a very low heat , add salt.
Now add in reserved water .
When oil starts to float to top of the curry , add cut gatte pieces .
Keep on simmer , close lid and cook for 5 minutes for flavours to get absorbed.
Turn off the heat , add chopped coriander leaves , stir well and serve .
Serve Gatte ki sabji with steamed rice or roti.